Best Fertilizer for Perennial Flowers: No More Than 1 lb of Nitrogen per 1,000 Sq Ft, and Phosphorus Only if Your Soil Test Asks

Best fertilizer for perennial flowers: how much phosphate each label really adds, where Michigan State, UConn and Wisconsin disagree, and what to buy.

In short

  • Best fertilizer for perennial flowers: slow-release or 20-5-10, once in spring, usually at most 1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft without compost (Michigan State).
  • High phosphorus doesn’t raise flower number (NDSU); 60–67% of urban soil tests in two Missouri areas read high or very high.
  • A soil test decides the phosphorus; a high reading means a low- or no-phosphorus label.
  • Checked against: NDSU, Michigan State, UConn.

University of Missouri Extension’s summary of 2008 urban lawn, garden and landscape soil tests (published 2010) found high or very high phosphorus in 60% of samples from the greater St. Louis area and 67% from the greater Kansas City area. Meanwhile a product such as Miracle-Gro’s Bloom Booster is sold as 15-30-15 and, on the manufacturer’s page, listed “For all flowering annuals and perennials.” That gap between what soils already hold and what bags promise is the place to start when you pick the best fertilizer for perennial flowers.

The short answer: most perennials need less than the bag suggests, and there is rarely a reason for extra phosphorus unless a soil test shows a need. Michigan State University Extension suggests one spring feeding of a slow-release product, or a balanced fertilizer such as 20-5-10, and calls no more than 1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft, if no compost is used, “the most common recommendation.” It also notes that many perennial experts recommend no fertilizer at all in healthy garden soil. The rest of this guide covers what to buy, how much phosphorus each label really puts down (we did the arithmetic), which form suits which plant, and the places where the extension sources disagree.

What to buy: the decision in one table

Your soil test result decides the label, and the table turns each result into something you can shop for. If you can’t test, the sources point to a low-phosphorus middle ground such as Michigan State’s 20-5-10; that is our reading of them, not a figure any one of them gives for untested beds.

Free pre-planned garden bed printables

Three pre-planned garden beds, free

Stop staring at empty beds: printable plans with exact layouts, plant lists and planting calendars — yours free from the Garden Library.

Your situationLabel to look forWhere it comes from
Soil test says phosphorus is high, or that none is needed20-0-10 if you can find one (Michigan State); otherwise 10-5-10, 20-5-10 or 25-5-5 (Wisconsin, for a high phosphorus test)Michigan State; Wisconsin
No soil testA slow-release product at its label rate, or a balanced 20-5-10Michigan State
Soil test says phosphorus is lowThe grade on your report; UConn describes flower fertilizers with nitrogen at or below phosphorus, such as 10-10-10 or 5-10-5UConn
Sandy soil with little organic matterRoutine, light fertilizing (Michigan State); compost helps sandy soil hold nutrients (Iowa State)Michigan State; Iowa State
Healthy soil with 1–2 inches of compost every yearPossibly nothingMichigan State (Iowa State disagrees; see the compost section)

No row says “bloom booster.” The one row where a phosphorus-forward grade belongs is the one where your own soil test says phosphorus is low.

Why extra phosphorus rarely helps flowers

Extra phosphorus doesn’t add flowers, and in many gardens it’s already in the soil. NDSU Extension horticulturist Esther McGinnis writes that “studies show that high phosphorus rates do not increase the number of flowers” and that in northern states “the soil in most gardens contains sufficient levels of phosphorus.” Her advice: “Unless a soil test shows otherwise, there is no need to add high phosphorus fertilizers.” Even a balanced 10-10-10 “is considered a waste of phosphorus.”

The mechanism explains why this keeps happening. Unlike nitrogen and potassium, phosphorus “doesn’t leach out of the soil. It is tied up by soil minerals and slowly released to growing plants,” according to Alabama Extension’s soil-test summary, which was written for vegetable gardens. So it accumulates: the University of Wisconsin-Extension says very high or excessive phosphorus levels “occasionally build up in garden soils, primarily because of past use of commercial fertilizer, manure, or compost.” A surplus then does damage instead of good. NDSU says it “ties up important plant micronutrients such as iron and zinc,” and Alabama Extension adds that excess phosphorus combined with soil pH above 6.5 can induce zinc and iron deficiencies, which “are difficult to correct because they are caused by an imbalance.”

Our breakdown of why extra phosphorus doesn’t actually make more flowers covers that mechanism, the exceptions and the state lawn-fertilizer bans. This guide spends its words on the buying decision instead.

How much to apply, and how much phosphorus comes with it

1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft is the most common ceiling for one perennial feeding when no compost is used, about a quarter of what a lawn gets in a growing season.

Source: Michigan State University Extension, Fertilizing established perennials (2012)

That ceiling is the figure to keep in your head, and the label decides how much phosphorus rides along with it. Per pound of nitrogen, a 15-30-15 bloom-booster label puts down eight times the phosphate of the 20-5-10 that Michigan State names. The phosphate is a percentage of the bag, so a bigger middle number delivers more of it every time you spread enough product to supply the nitrogen.

UConn’s sheet shows the conversion: 10 lb of 10-10-10 supplies 1 lb each of nitrogen, phosphate (P2O5) and potash (K2O) per 1,000 sq ft, and 10 lb of 5-10-5 supplies ½ lb of nitrogen, 1 lb of phosphate and ½ lb of potash. Dividing 1 lb by the nitrogen percentage gives the pounds of product needed for 1 lb of nitrogen, and multiplying that by the phosphate percentage gives the phosphate that comes with it.

LabelProduct for 1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ftPhosphate (P2O5) deliveredCompared with 20-5-10
20-0-105.0 lb0 lbNone
20-5-105.0 lb0.25 lbBaseline
10-10-1010 lb1.0 lb4 times as much
5-10-520 lb2.0 lb8 times as much
15-30-156.7 lb2.0 lb8 times as much

The 10-10-10 row comes straight from UConn, the 5-10-5 row is UConn’s figure scaled to 1 lb of nitrogen, and the rest is our arithmetic using the same method. Use the table to compare labels, not as application rates: a water-soluble product such as the 15-30-15 is dosed by the tablespoon per gallon, not by the pound per 1,000 sq ft.

Frequency widens the gap. The Miracle-Gro page’s directions call for 1 tablespoon per gallon of water for outdoor plants and a soak at the base of each plant “every 7 to 14 days.” UConn gives established perennials one spring application, with a second 6 to 8 weeks later only for plants with long-lasting foliage or an extended bloom period, and Wisconsin says twice a year. We’re not saying the product is unsafe or that its nitrogen and potassium do nothing. We found nothing in the extension sheets that asks perennials for a weekly or biweekly feed.

A worked example for a 10 × 15 ft border (150 sq ft) at 1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft, which is 0.15 lb of nitrogen: that’s 0.75 lb of 20-5-10, or about 1½ cups, or 1.5 lb of 10-10-10, about 3 cups. The cup figures use UConn’s rule of thumb that a cup of granular synthetic fertilizer weighs about ½ lb; weigh your own product once, because densities differ.

Slow-release, granular or liquid: matching the form to the plant

For most perennials, a slow-release granular fed once in spring is the low-effort choice, and liquids are the tool for corrections and for the few plants that want a second feed. That pattern runs through Iowa State’s and Michigan State’s advice, and the table puts the sources side by side.

FormWhat the extension sources sayBest use for perennialsThe catch
Slow-release granulesIowa State: released over several weeks or months, so “one application in spring may be all that is necessary.” Michigan State: products usually act over a 3–4 month or a 5–6 month window.One feeding of a whole border; pick the 5–6 month product if you will feed only onceRelease speed depends on placement (see below)
Fast-dissolving granulesIowa State: water-soluble granules dissolve fast. UConn, on granular feeds in general: nutrients last about 6–8 weeks.Split feeding: spring, then again 6–8 weeks later for long bloomersUConn: heavy rain or frequent irrigation can leach granular nutrients, so a reapplication may be needed
LiquidIowa State: fast-acting. Michigan State: spot-treat for a quick green-up when cold soil leaves foliage pale, and for perennials you cut back to rebloom (delphinium, daisy, pulmonaria).Corrections and the second feed for heavy feedersShort-lived, and Iowa State advises against applying fertilizer when the soil is dry because it raises the chance of burning foliage
Slow-release pellets, loose granules and a water-soluble feed dissolving in water on a garden table
AI-generated illustration of the three forms compared in the table above: coated slow-release pellets, loose mixed granules and a water-soluble feed dissolving in a jug. It shows no real product.

“Slow-release” also depends on where the granules sit. In a peer-reviewed study of urea fertilizers rated to release over 45 to 180 days, Ransom and colleagues found that polymer-coated products incorporated into the soil “do have a controlled release approximate to what is expected,” while surface-applied they “released their N within 35 d.” Held at constant temperatures instead, the polymer-coated products released slowly, under 80% over the whole study, so the paper names both placement and temperature as influences. Sulfur-coated products showed minimal slow-release properties whatever the placement.

35 days: polymer-coated urea products rated for 45 to 180 days released their nitrogen within 35 days when surface applied, under daily fluctuating temperatures.

Source: Ransom et al., PLoS ONE 15(6), 2020

The study used agricultural urea products and framed its work around semi-arid conditions, so it can’t tell you what a particular garden bag will do. We found no trial that compares topdressed and scratched-in garden products on perennials. It does give a plausible reason why a “season-long” product spread on the surface can run out early, and it is consistent with UConn’s instruction to pull mulch back, scratch granules lightly into the soil and water them in. Treat that link as our inference, not a finding.

Not every perennial reads the same table. Michigan State lists daylilies, peony, chrysanthemum and tall phlox as heavier feeders that benefit from a spring feeding and a second one in summer, using a product that is available immediately or a liquid. Our daylily fertilizer guide explains the 6-to-8-week second feeding that repeat bloomers need. Peony is the plant where our own guide leans toward restraint: it focuses on the spring nitrogen trap that stops peonies from blooming, so read it before adding a second feed. Native wildflowers sit at the other end: for New England woodland and meadow natives, UConn says nutrient requirements are generally low and recommends one spring application, or one at bed preparation.

How often: where four sources differ

Michigan State, UConn and Wisconsin all tie the main feeding to the start of spring growth, and Iowa State says one spring application of a slow-release product may be enough. They split on whether there is a second feeding and on new plantings.

SourceEstablished perennialsNew plantingsLong bloomers and heavy feeders
Michigan State (2012)One feeding just before or as spring growth pushes up; many experts recommend none in healthy soilNot coveredSecond feeding in summer for daylily, peony, chrysanthemum, tall phlox
UConn (2015)The recommended rate when growth resumes in springRate at bed preparation, same rate again 6–8 weeks laterSecond feeding 6–8 weeks later for long-lasting foliage or extended bloom
Wisconsin (1988)Half the recommended rate in spring when growth begins, repeated in late June or early JulyNot coveredNot singled out
Iowa StateFor slow-release products, one spring application may be all that is necessaryPerennials “rarely need fertilizer during the first growing season”Not covered

Our reading: feed once in spring, add a second feeding only for long-blooming or heavy-feeding plants, and let a soil test break the tie for a first-year planting, where UConn feeds twice and Iowa State says plants rarely need any. The sources don’t reconcile that last point, so we don’t pretend they do.

The stop date is clearer. Michigan State says not to fertilize perennials in late summer or early fall, because it may push out new growth that “will not harden off in time for an early winter freeze.”

Perennial flower border in full bloom with coneflower, salvia and daylilies
AI-generated illustration of a well-grown border. Over-fed perennials, Michigan State warns, grow floppy and leggy and can trade blooms for foliage.

Compost instead of fertilizer? Michigan State and Iowa State disagree

Compost can replace the fertilizer in some beds but not in all, and the two sources give opposite answers. Michigan State says topdressing a perennial bed with 1 to 2 inches of compost “will provide season-long fertility for most perennials,” and that if you routinely apply a 1-inch layer of compost or leaf mold each year you can often eliminate fertilizing altogether. Iowa State says compost “should not be considered a substitute for fertilizer but rather a supplement,” because nutrient release is slow and the content is often too low to supply everything a plant needs. It adds that compost helps soil hold and release nutrients, especially sandy soil.

Hmm, that email didn't go through. Double-check the address and try again.
You're in — your first tips are on the way. Check your inbox (and your spam folder, just in case).

Zone-Smart Gardening Tips, Delivered Free Every Week

Most gardening advice online is too vague to help — or written for a climate nothing like yours. Every week, Blooming Expert sends you specific, zone-aware tips you can put to work in your garden right now.

No fluff. No daily emails. Just one focused tip, every week.

They can both be right for different beds. Compost is also a phosphorus source: Wisconsin lists compost, alongside commercial fertilizer and manure, among the causes of phosphorus build-up. A bed that already tests high needs a test before more compost, not after. Our guide to composting flower beds covers how to apply it.

How to read a soil test, and what a high phosphorus result means

Iowa State’s advice: “Always start with a soil test to determine the amount of fertilizer needed.” Labs report on different scales, so use the scale printed on your own report. One example: the University of Missouri summary above rates phosphorus very low under 20, low at 20–40, medium at 41–60, high at 61–120 and very high above 120 pounds per acre.

When the phosphorus reading is very high, Wisconsin says the report will recommend 0 lb of phosphate per 100 sq ft, yet may still suggest a mixed grade such as 10-5-10, because a phosphorus-free mixed fertilizer is hard to buy. That is where the sources split on what to purchase.

SourceWhat to buy when phosphorus tests highWhat it says about finding it
Wisconsin (1988)A low-phosphorus mix: 10-5-10, 20-5-10 or 25-5-5; better still, apply nitrogen and potassium separately“Fertilizers such as 10-0-10 or 20-0-10 are not commercially available”
Michigan State (2012)A product such as 20-0-10No availability note
Alabama (2019)A mixed fertilizer with no phosphorus such as 15-0-15, or 33-0-0 for nitrogen plus 0-0-60 muriate of potash“These may be difficult to find”

So a phosphorus-free mixed fertilizer is the textbook answer and a hard one to shop for: two sources, 31 years apart, say it can be scarce, while Michigan State names 20-0-10 without a caveat. If you can’t find one, Wisconsin’s low-phosphorus mixes are the fallback. If your report gives numbers you can’t read, our free Soil Test Interpreter takes your pH and your phosphorus and potassium bands and returns plain-language next steps.

What your plants are telling you

Most feeding mistakes show up as one of a few symptoms. The table matches each to its likely cause and the fix.

What you seeLikely causeWhat to doSource
Tall, floppy stems, lots of foliage, few flowersOver-fertilizing: excess growth that flops, at the expense of bloomsSkip the next feeding and avoid high-nitrogen products on the bedMichigan State
Pale green or yellow foliage in cold early springCool soil limiting uptake of some nutrientsWait for the soil to warm; if it persists, spot-treat with a liquid feedMichigan State
Young leaves yellow while the veins stay greenIron deficiency, which excess phosphorus can induce, particularly with pH above 6.5; high pH alone also lowers iron availabilitySoil test for pH and phosphorus; stop phosphorus inputs if it is highAlabama; Wisconsin; NDSU
Dwarfed new growth with yellow striping between veins in early springZinc deficiency, likewise induced by excess phosphorus with high pHSoil test before adding anything; this is an imbalance, not a simple shortageAlabama (symptoms described mainly on corn)
Burned leaf edges or a scorched crown after feedingGranules clustered in the crown, or fertilizer applied to dry soilBrush granules off the crown, keep them 2–4 inches from it, and water inMichigan State; Iowa State; Wisconsin; UConn
Thin growth year after year in sandy soil with little organic matterSoil that holds few nutrients; plants there “will probably benefit from routine, light fertilization”Routine, light fertilizing plus compostMichigan State; Iowa State
Soft new growth killed by an early freezeA feeding in late summer or early fallDon’t feed perennials in late summer or early fall; resume next springMichigan State

Which one should you choose?

Match your own bed to one of these lines. Each follows from the sources above.

  • If your soil test says phosphorus is high or very high, choose a no- or low-phosphorus label (20-0-10, or 20-5-10 if you can’t find it) and feed once in spring.
  • If you haven’t tested and have fed the bed for years, skip the bloom booster, use a 20-5-10 at no more than 1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft, and test before next season.
  • If your soil is sandy and low in organic matter, feed lightly and routinely and add compost.
  • If you grow long bloomers or heavy feeders, add a second feeding 6 to 8 weeks after the first (UConn) or in summer (Michigan State), liquid or fast-release.
  • If your soil test says phosphorus is low, buy the grade your report names.

Perennials aren’t the only flowering plants that punish heavy feeding. Potentilla, a flowering shrub, follows the same restraint logic with a two-feed schedule, and our perennial flowers growing guide covers the rest of the care routine. Your next step is the soil sample: send it before spring so the report is in hand when growth resumes.

FAQ

What is the best fertilizer for perennial flowers?

Michigan State Extension recommends a slow-release product, or a balanced fertilizer such as 20-5-10, applied once in spring. It calls no more than 1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft, if no compost is used, “the most common recommendation.” If your soil test shows no need for phosphorus, it suggests a product such as 20-0-10, though Wisconsin and Alabama report that no-phosphorus mixes can be hard to find (see the soil test section).

Do perennial flowers need a bloom booster?

No, not unless a soil test shows low phosphorus. NDSU Extension says studies show high phosphorus rates do not increase the number of flowers, and that most northern garden soils already contain enough of it.

When should you fertilize perennials?

As growth resumes in spring. Long bloomers can take a second feeding 6 to 8 weeks later (UConn), and Wisconsin repeats a half-rate feeding in late June or early July. Michigan State says not to feed perennials in late summer or early fall.

Is 10-10-10 okay for perennials?

It depends on your soil. UConn describes flower fertilizers with nitrogen at or below phosphorus, such as 10-10-10, and sets rates from a soil test. NDSU says even a balanced 10-10-10 is considered a waste of phosphorus, and that most northern garden soils already have enough, so a lower-phosphorus label is the better default unless your test says phosphorus is low.

Is compost enough to feed perennials?

The two sources differ. Michigan State says 1 to 2 inches of compost gives season-long fertility for most perennials, while Iowa State calls compost a supplement, not a substitute for fertilizer. A soil test is the tie-breaker.

Should new perennials be fertilized in the first year?

The sources disagree. UConn applies the recommended rate at bed preparation and again 6 to 8 weeks later, while Iowa State says new perennials rarely need fertilizer in their first growing season. Let your soil test decide.

Sources

  1. NDSU Extension (McGinnis, E.). Dakota Gardener: The myth of high phosphorus fertilizers for more flowers. NDSU Agriculture Communication, August 15, 2023
  2. Michigan State University Extension (Finneran, R.). Fertilizing established perennials – feed ’em and weep. Published May 2012
  3. University of Connecticut CAHNR (Pettinelli, D.). Suggested Fertilizer Practices for Flowers. 2001, revised 2015
  4. University of Wisconsin-Extension (Schulte, E.E. and Combs, S.M.). Garden Fertilization, A2304. 1988
  5. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach. Fertilizing in the Home Garden. Yard and Garden
  6. University of Missouri Extension IPM (Nathan, M.). Soil Test Summary for Urban Lawns and Garden Soils. Published 2010, revised 2015
  7. Alabama Cooperative Extension System (Smith, K. et al.). Excessive Phosphorus In Garden Soils, excerpt of The Alabama Vegetable Gardener, ANR-0479. February 26, 2019
  8. Ransom, C.J., Jolley, V.D., Blair, T.A., Sutton, L.E. and Hopkins, B.G. Nitrogen release rates from slow- and controlled-release fertilizers influenced by placement and temperature. PLoS ONE 15(6): e0234544, 2020
  9. Scotts Miracle-Gro. Miracle-Gro Water Soluble Bloom Booster Flower Food (product page; the page notes it is not the product label)
Also free:

This helped. Make sure the next one finds you. One tap marks Blooming Expert as a favourite source. Google stops serving generic content and starts surfacing zone-specific care guides and seasonal advice that fit what you actually grow — right in your regular feed.
Add Blooming Expert to Google →
3 Views
Scroll to top
Close
Browse Categories
Browse Tags
Browse Authors
Free Tools Calendar Companions Planner Frost Soil All 10