Ethylene Chart for 30 Garden Crops: Which to Store Apart, and the 0.2 ppm Level That Starts Carrots Turning Bitter
Ethylene chart rating 30 garden crops from USDA Handbook 66: which give off the gas, which it damages, and how to store them apart in a fridge or cellar.
In short
- Ethylene-producing fruits and vegetables: apples, pears, ripe peaches and plums, cantaloupe and tomatoes.
- Carrots, broccoli, cauliflower, cucumbers and watermelon are damaged by it; carrots start making a bitter compound at about 0.2 ppm.
- How much damage depends on temperature and exposure time (UC Davis).
- Checked against: USDA Handbook 66, UC Davis Postharvest, University of Kentucky Extension.
Ethylene-producing fruits and vegetables are mainly apples, pears, ripe peaches and plums, cantaloupe and tomatoes. The gas speeds up ripening and aging, which yellows, softens or embitters crops meant to stay firm: USDA Agriculture Handbook 66 calls broccoli, cauliflower and Brussels sprouts extremely sensitive, and carrots can turn bitter. Keep the two groups in separate containers or rooms.
That is the short answer. The long one is more useful, because the same handbook rates garden crops one by one and some ratings surprise: potatoes, onions, garlic, grapes and strawberries are all rated little affected. This guide gives a 30-crop chart, the temperature-and-time rule that decides how much damage you actually get, and a fridge and cellar plan built from it. It also shows how to turn the gas to your advantage when you want an avocado or pear to ripen.
Which fruits and vegetables produce ethylene?
Ethylene (C2H4) is a colorless gas that plants make from the amino acid methionine, and most plants make small amounts of it that appear to coordinate growth and development. The crops that matter in storage are climacteric fruit. HB66 names apples, avocados, bananas, melons, pears and tomatoes: once ripening starts, their own ethylene switches on more ethylene, and the handbook says this feedback can raise production and internal concentration about 1,000-fold.

Three pre-planned garden beds, free
Stop staring at empty beds: printable plans with exact layouts, plant lists and planting calendars — yours free from the Garden Library.
Ripe fruit is not the only source. Handbook 66 lists diseased and wounded tissue, and exhaust from engines and fires, as sources that can build up in an enclosed room. It reports that cut, bruised or wounded potato tubers, and wounded pumpkins, give off far more than intact ones. A rotting apple in the cellar is therefore a source worth removing.
Ethylene chart: 30 garden crops, what each gives off and what it does
The chart below comes from Handbook 66’s Table 1 and the ethylene section of each crop’s chapter. Output is in microliters of ethylene per kilogram of produce per hour (µL kg-1 h-1) at 68°F (20°C) unless a row says otherwise. HB66 itself calls 0.1 to 1.0 “low” (watermelon) and 1 to 10 “moderate” (tomato). We use “High” for anything above 10, a label the handbook does not print, and “Low” for everything under 1, including the crops it calls very low. The sensitivity column quotes the handbook’s own words, and where it gives no rating the cell says so.
| Crop | Gives off (µL kg-1 h-1) | Sensitivity, in HB66’s words | What ethylene does to it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Group 1: crops that give off ethylene | |||
| Apple | High in early-season varieties, low in late ones; “varies greatly” | Exposure advances ripening | Ripening starts sooner |
| Pear | High once ripening starts | “Somewhat sensitive” before ripe: Bartlett most, Bosc and Comice moderately, d’Anjou least | Triggers ripening |
| Peach | High when ripe: 0.1 to 160 | Well-mature fruit “will ripen properly without exogenous ethylene” | Added ethylene mostly evens out ripening |
| Plum | High when ripe: 0.1 to 200 | Well-mature fruit “will ripen properly without exogenous ethylene” | Needed only for slow-ripening cultivars |
| Cantaloupe (netted melon) | High: 10 to 100 | “Postharvest exposure to ethylene reduces shelf-life and should be avoided” | Shorter shelf life |
| Tomato | Moderate: 1 to 10 | Sensitive: 0.5 µL L-1 is enough to trigger ripening | Starts ripening |
| Raspberry | Moderate to high: 1 to 12, by cultivar | No rating given | Stimulates gray mold; red berries darken to purple-red |
| Asparagus | “Low to intermediate”: 2.1 to 3.1 soon after cutting | No rating given | Spears toughen (lignification) |
| Group 2: low producers that ethylene damages | |||
| Carrot | Low: under 0.1 | “Should not be exposed to ethylene in storage” | Bitter compound (isocoumarin) from about 0.2 µL L-1 |
| Parsnip | Low: under 0.1 | Low levels in cold storage cause bitterness | Bitterness, likely from xanthotoxin |
| Broccoli | Low: under 0.1 | “Extremely sensitive” | Floret yellowing; 2 µL L-1 at 50°F halves shelf life |
| Cauliflower | Low: under 1 | “Extremely sensitive” | Curd discoloration, leaf yellowing and leaf drop |
| Brussels sprouts | Low: under 0.25 at 46°F | “Extremely sensitive” | Leaf yellowing and leaf drop |
| Cabbage | Low: under 0.1 | “Should not be exposed to ethylene after harvest” | From 1 µL L-1: leaf yellowing, wilting, leaf drop |
| Lettuce | Low: “very low” | “Very susceptible” to ethylene-induced disorders | Russet spotting, leaf yellowing |
| Spinach (leafy greens) | Low: under 0.1 | “All leafy greens are sensitive” | No symptom named: the printed sentence breaks off |
| Cucumber | Low: 0.1 to 1.0 | “Very sensitive” | 1 to 5 µL L-1 speeds yellowing and decay |
| Eggplant | Low: 0.1 to 0.7 at 55°F | “Moderate to high sensitivity” | Above 1 µL L-1: calyx drop and browning |
| Snap bean | Low: under 0.05 at 41°F | Affected above 0.1 µL L-1 | Chlorophyll loss and browning; storage life cut 30 to 50% at 41°F |
| Pea | Low: under 0.1 | “Moderately sensitive” | Yellowing and decay; the calyx is more sensitive than the pod |
| Watermelon | Low: 0.1 to 1.0 | “Extremely sensitive” | 5 µL L-1 softens fruit, thins the rind and fades the flesh |
| Pepper | Low: 0.2 (0.1 at 50°F) | No rating; “store them away from ethylene-producing fruits” | Raises respiration and softening more than color |
| Summer squash | Low: 0.1 to 1.0 | No rating given | Green-skinned types may yellow |
| Winter squash and pumpkin | Low: trace amounts | Dark-green types “should not be stored near apples” | Skin turns orange-yellow; stems may drop |
| Group 3: little affected | |||
| Potato | Low: under 0.1 (more if cut or bruised) | “Not very sensitive” | Low levels: weight loss, mild shriveling; may change sprouting |
| Sweet potato | Not given | Exposure “should be avoided”, yet a “relatively minor concern” with proper ventilation | Raises phenolic compounds, so roots discolor |
| Onion | Low: under 0.1 | Sensitivity “also low” | Sprouting encouraged above 1,500 µL L-1 |
| Garlic | Low: “very low” | “Not particularly sensitive” | No effect listed |
| Grape | Low: under 0.1 | “Not very sensitive” | No effect listed |
| Strawberry | Low: under 0.1 | “They do not respond to ethylene” | Removing ethylene may reduce disease |
The chart’s biggest takeaway is that eight of the 30 crops are real ethylene sources, sixteen show damage from it, and six are little affected. The damaged group includes leafy greens and brassicas, plus carrots, cucumbers and watermelon. Cucumber (rated “very sensitive”) and watermelon (“extremely sensitive”) are the two that a gardener is most likely to stack beside a tomato or cantaloupe, which sit in the producer group.

2 µL L-1 at 50°F (10°C) of ethylene halves the shelf life of broccoli, which produces under 0.1 µL kg-1 h-1 itself.
Source: USDA ARS, Agriculture Handbook 66 (2016), Broccoli chapter
Why the damage depends on temperature and exposure time
Whether a sensitive crop is damaged depends on temperature and exposure time, not only on who sits next to whom. UC Davis Postharvest’s Michael Reid answers a question from a produce handler on this by writing that the response “is very much a time/temperature relationship.” His example is lettuce: ethylene causes russet spotting above 39°F (4°C), but storage at 32°F (0°C) eliminates the problem. His advice where mixing producers and sensitive crops cannot be avoided is to hold the proper storage temperature and give the room at least one air exchange per hour with outside air, which lowers both the crop’s sensitivity and the ethylene it meets.
Handbook 66 says the same thing from the plant’s side. Celery “is not very sensitive to low concentrations of ethylene when exposed at low temperatures,” but above 41°F (5°C) levels higher than 10 µL L-1 speed yellowing and pithiness. The handbook also notes that the response is log-linear, so each tenfold rise in ethylene adds the same step of response over a very wide range, and it lists “minimize time between exposure and use” and “maintain at coldest possible temperature” among the ways to reduce ethylene’s effect. For watermelon it concedes that the interactions between concentration, temperature and duration “are not well defined.”
For a home cook this means the chart ranks risk but does not give a safe number of days. We found no source that measures ethylene in a home refrigerator or cellar, so how many days a carrot survives beside an apple is not something any of them can tell you. Your protection is to cut all three variables at once: less ethylene, colder storage, and a shorter stay.
Why do apples make carrots bitter?
Apples give off ethylene, and ethylene makes carrots build a bitter compound. The University of Kentucky’s home gardening guide puts it plainly: “Do not store carrots in the same room as apples. Apples give off ethylene, which causes carrots to become bitter.” The chemistry is in Handbook 66: carrots produce almost none themselves, but exposure to about 0.2 µL L-1 induces the bitter compound isocoumarin.
About 0.2 µL L-1 (0.2 ppm) of ethylene is where HB66 says carrots begin developing isocoumarin, the compound behind the bitter taste.
Source: USDA ARS, Agriculture Handbook 66 (2016), Carrot chapter
UC Davis’s carrot fact sheet measures the effect at a different point: as little as 0.5 ppm of added ethylene gives a perceptible bitter flavor within 2 weeks at normal storage conditions. The two numbers probably do not conflict. One is where the compound starts to form, the other is where a taster notices it.
Two details help you diagnose a bitter batch. First, HB66 reports that peeled carrot exposed to ethylene does not develop bitterness, so the compound forms mainly in the peel (HB66 measured cut sections). Second, ethylene is not the only cause: the same UC Davis sheet says bitterness may also come from preharvest stress such as improper irrigation scheduling, and the handbook says disease can do it too. If your bitter carrots never shared a room with fruit, look at the summer watering before you blame the apples. Parsnips also turn bitter after low-level exposure in cold storage, though the handbook points to a different compound, xanthotoxin.
Where the sources disagree, and how to read it
Handbook 66, UC Davis and the extension guides rarely contradict each other outright, but they do give different numbers for the same crop. The table shows three differences we found that change what you do at home.
| Question | One source says | Another says | How to read it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lettuce: when does ethylene cause russet spots? | UC Davis: above 39°F (4°C); storage at 32°F (0°C) eliminates it | HB66: spots form at about 41°F (5°C); keep the air ethylene-free and below 36°F (2°C) | Aim as close to freezing as the crisper allows; the two limits are within a few degrees |
| Carrots: how little ethylene matters? | HB66: about 0.2 µL L-1 induces the bitter compound | UC Davis: 0.5 ppm gives perceptible bitterness within 2 weeks | Different endpoints: formation versus taste |
| Tomato: how much does it give off? | HB66 chapter text: 1 to 10 µL kg-1 h-1 | HB66 Table 1: 10.0 at 68°F | Table 1 prints the top of the chapter’s range; the chart above uses the chapter’s “moderate” |
A home refrigerator runs at about 40°F, according to the University of Minnesota, which is above both UC Davis’s 39°F line for lettuce and HB66’s 36°F control point. By that arithmetic a fridge at 40°F gives lettuce little temperature protection, so lettuce is the crop to keep farthest from apples.
Odor is a second reason to separate crops, and it is not ethylene. Washington State University Extension advises avoiding apples or pears with celery, cabbage, carrots, potatoes or onions because some crops pick up off-odors from their neighbors. In the next paragraph it names apples, pears and tomatoes as ethylene producers. Handbook 66 rates potatoes “not very sensitive” and onions low, so the main reason to keep potatoes away from apples is flavor, not the gas.
How to store ethylene producers apart: fridge and cellar
Give the producers a space of their own and the sensitive crops another, and use the temperature each group needs. The University of Minnesota describes refrigerators as cold and dry (40°F and 50 to 60% relative humidity), good for garlic and onions “but not much else,” and says perforated plastic bags give cold, moist conditions for a moderate time while unperforated bags often cause condensation and mold. In practice, that puts carrots, broccoli and greens in perforated bags in one drawer, and apples and pears in a different drawer or container. WSU Extension agrees that the groups “should be stored separately for longest storage life.”
The cellar is the harder case, because the crops that want the same conditions are also the ones that clash. University of Maine Bulletin 4135 lists apples at 30 to 40°F and 90 to 95% humidity, and mature carrots at 32°F and 98 to 100%. That is nearly the same cold, moist room, so a shelf is not enough: Kentucky says not the same room. If you have only one cellar, use lidded containers for the apples, check them often, and remove any that start to rot, since HB66 names diseased tissue as a significant ethylene source. Our guide to storing apples covers keeping them sound.
The cool shelf (45 to 55°F) cannot be solved by temperature at all. The University of Kentucky’s HortFact 7002 puts ripe tomatoes at 45 to 50°F, cucumbers and eggplant at 50 to 55°F, peppers at 45 to 50°F and watermelon at 50 to 55°F. A tomato (producer) and a cucumber (very sensitive) therefore want the same shelf, and only distance or a separate container keeps them apart. Our potato storage guide and onion curing guide cover two crops the chart puts in the low-risk group.
Using ethylene on purpose: ripening avocados, pears and tomatoes
You can put the same gas to work. Iowa State Extension says to place unripe avocados in a brown paper bag with an apple or banana for two to three days, because the fruit’s ethylene triggers ripening and the bag helps contain it. UC Agriculture and Natural Resources advises 3 or 4 avocados in a loosely closed paper bag with 2 to 3 Red or Golden Delicious apples or ripe kiwifruit, kept at about 68°F, and warns against a plastic bag unless it is left open.
Tomatoes are the second use. Handbook 66 says as little as 0.5 µL L-1 triggers ripening in a tomato, and that once a fruit reaches the breaker stage it makes enough ethylene to need no more. By our reading, a ripe banana or apple is useful only to a mature-green tomato that has not started to color. Our green tomato guide covers the paper-bag method and timing.
Pears are different. Handbook 66 says optimally mature pears need chilling at 30°F before they ripen normally: about 60 days for d’Anjou, 30 days for Bosc and Comice and 15 days for Bartlett. Commercially, ethylene at 100 µL L-1 for 2 to 3 days has been used to precondition under-chilled Bartlett and d’Anjou pears. None of the sources cited here measures the dose from a bag with an apple, and the extension pages describe the bag method only for avocados, so chill home-grown pears first and use a bag only to finish them.
Frequently asked questions
Which fruits and vegetables produce the most ethylene?
Per Handbook 66, the highest rates in our chart come from ripe peaches and plums (up to 160 and 200 µL kg-1 h-1), cantaloupe (10 to 100), and pears once they ripen; apples vary greatly, high in early-season varieties. Washington State University Extension names apples, pears and tomatoes as the producers to store separately, and Handbook 66 lists all three among the climacteric fruit.
Can you store apples and potatoes together?
Ethylene is not the main issue, because Handbook 66 rates potatoes not very sensitive. Washington State University Extension still advises avoiding apples or pears with potatoes because crops can pick up off-odors from their neighbors.
Does a banana really help ripen avocados?
It helps, according to Iowa State Extension, which advises putting unripe avocados in a brown paper bag with an apple or banana for two to three days, because the fruit’s ethylene triggers ripening and the bag helps contain it.
Does refrigeration stop ethylene damage?
It lowers a crop’s sensitivity. UC Davis says damage is a time and temperature relationship and that holding the proper temperature lowers a crop’s sensitivity, though kiwifruit stays sensitive even at 32°F (0°C).
Why do carrots turn bitter in storage?
Ethylene from nearby fruit such as apples is one cause, and Handbook 66 puts the trigger at about 0.2 µL L-1. UC Davis also lists preharvest irrigation stress, and the handbook lists disease.
What to do this week
Walk your fridge and cellar with the chart in hand. Move apples, pears and ripe tomatoes to their own drawer, bag or room, and put carrots, broccoli, cabbage and greens on the far side of the cellar or in a perforated bag in the crisper. Check the apples for rot every week, and see our guide to storing vegetables and fruit from the garden for the temperature and humidity each crop wants. If the harvest is bigger than the shelf, our guide to preserving garden vegetables sorts out canning, freezing, drying, fermenting and cellar storage.
Sources
- USDA Agricultural Research Service. The Commercial Storage of Fruits, Vegetables, and Florist and Nursery Stocks, Agriculture Handbook 66 (2016 revision). USDA ARS
- Reid, M. Can you help me with more detailed information about ethylene compatibility of produce? UC Davis Postharvest Research and Extension Center, Ask the Produce Experts
- UC Davis Postharvest Research and Extension Center. Carrot: Produce Facts Sheet. University of California, Davis
- University of Kentucky Cooperative Extension. Home Vegetable Gardening in Kentucky, ID-128. University of Kentucky
- Coolong, T. Recommended Storage Conditions for Vegetables, HortFact 7002. University of Kentucky Horticulture Department
- University of Maine Cooperative Extension. Storage Conditions: Fruits and Vegetables, Bulletin 4135. University of Maine
- Tong, C. Harvesting and Storing Home Garden Vegetables, FS-01424 (archived 2009 copy). University of Minnesota Extension
- Wolfe, K. Storing Your Garden Harvest (2019). Washington State University Extension
- Iowa State University Extension and Outreach. Avocados 101, AnswerLine
- University of California Cooperative Extension. When an Avocado is Ripe. UC Agriculture and Natural Resources









